Looking for the best afternoon tea in NYC? If so then you’ve come to the right place!
After all, I’m a 30+ year NYC local who is utterly obsessed with enjoying afternoon tea in NYC and beyond (yes London and Edinburgh, I’m talking about you).
Therefore, I know exactly where to find the best scones, the tastiest finger sandwiches, and the most opulent New York afternoon tea experience in town.
So, put away the guidebook, forego the high price tag of afternoon tea in the Plaza, and learn all about super secret hidden gems where you can savor an afternoon tea to remember with close friends and family.
This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure for more information. As an Amazon Associate, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.
If you’re booking a trip right now then I IMPLORE you to get travel insurance – even if it’s not from me.
After all, this past year has been a wild ride and I don’t want you to lose money because government regulations have changed.
Truth be told though, I’ve never traveled without travel insurance and don’t think you should either – especially since I think we’ve all had plans drastically change because of the pandemic.
Therefore, find an insurance agency that covers travel changes related to COVID-19, like my two all-time faves World Nomads and Safety Wing. You can also read more about which policy is right for you in my full review here.
Best Afternoon Tea in NYC – Uptown
1. The Pembroke Room
Tucked away inside the Upper East Side’s famous Lowell Hotel, this refined, new American eatery has a reputation for serving the best afternoon tea in NYC.
So, ascend the grand marble staircase to the second floor and have a seat inside an exquisite, European-style salon – complete with crystal chandeliers – where you can indulge in the fine art of afternoon tea.
Service is also decadent and traditional.
Therefore, fresh scones, authentic French macarons, decadent pecan tarts, and lobster salad finger sandwiches are all served to you upon a three-tiered plate, complete with your choice of Dammann Feres loose leaf teas.
It’s not cheap but it’s a great New York afternoon tea experience if you want to treat yo’self.
Address: 28 East 63rd Street, New York, NY, 10065
Hours: Open daily from 12:00 pm to 7:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $50 per person.
How to Get There: Take the F train the Lexington and 63rd Street and walk from there.
2. Alice’s Tea Cup
This super enchanting tearoom on the Upper West Side has an Alice and Wonderland theme about it that both the big and little kids love.
In fact, people adore this place so much that there are now three different locations scattered throughout the city.
Truth be told though, the Upper West Side location (aka the original) is still my fave since it features vibrantly painted walls, mismatched tea sets, and stunning Alice and Wonderland decor around every turn.
Therefore, it makes for an incredibly whimsical locale from which to sip on tea, eat finger sandwiches, and indulge in fresh scones with clotted cream.
That’s why, if you’re looking for the best afternoon tea in NYC for kids then this place should be at the top of your list.
Then, all you have to do upon arrival is choose among the Nibble (small), Madhatter (medium), or Jabberwocky (large) afternoon tea – all of which come with lapsang-smoked chicken and tea-egg salad finger sandwiches served to you atop a three-tier plate.
Pro Tip: Do make a reservation to avoid a wait. Also, order the pumpkin scones if that is at all a possibility.
Address: 102 W 73rd St, New York, NY 10023
Hours: Open daily from 11:00 am to 6:00 pm.
Price: Afternoon tea for one starts at $36.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the 1/2/3 train to 72nd Street and walk from there.
3. King’s Carriage House
Looking for one of the best things to do on the Upper East Side that doubles as an iconic New York afternoon tea experience?
If so then run, don’t walk, to King’s Carriage House. A magical place that is not only one of the coolest restaurants in NYC, but that is a fantastic hidden gem that many people don’t know about.
So, skip the high price tag associated with tea at the Plaza and come here instead.
After all, their delicious, three-tiered tea service is well-priced at under $30.00 per person and can be enjoyed in a charming, colonial-style dining room on the second floor of this historic townhouse.
The service is also great since this place is cozy and you can indulge in fan faves like sesame chicken salad, goat cheese tartlets, fresh scones (with all the usually fix-ins), apricot coconut tea cakes, lemon curd squares, and a variety of high-end teas (I liked the cinnamon)!
Pro Tip: This is a great place to stop either before or after visiting the MET.
Address: 251 E 82nd St, New York, NY 10028
Hours: Open Sunday, Tuesday, and Wednesday from 12:00 pm to 5:00 pm and Thursday through Saturday from 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $29.95 per person for afternoon tea, with a high tea service priced at $39.95 per person.
How to Get There: Take the Q to 57th street station or the 4/5/6 train to 86th street station and walk from there.
4. The Gallery at the Carlyle
Originally built in 1930, The Carlyle is a historic, 5-star hotel is known for its lavish, three-tier, afternoon tea service, which is routinely enjoyed by foreign dignitaries and selfie-stick-wielding tourists alike.
So, if you would want to enjoy the best afternoon tea in NYC, then have a seat inside a stunning restaurant that is designed to mimic the lavish private dining room of the sultan at Topkapi Palace in Turkey.
Incredible decorative highlights include vibrant floral wallpaper, Middle-eastern patterned china, patterned pillows, and red velvet seats.
However, the only thing more impressive than the decor is the tea service – an incredible New York afternoon tea experience that includes a wide selection of premium teas (the hot cinnamon spice and spiced plum were my faves).
Then, once you have your tea in hand, devour reimagined takes on classic afternoon tea offerings like miniature pastries, English raisin scones (with double cream + strawberry preserves), and savories like Hudson Valley Fois Gras Torchon.
Pro Tip: If you’re not into tea that also serve Stumptown Coffee which is the BEST.
Address: 35 East 76th St., New York, NY 10021, USA
Hours: Served daily from 3:00 pm to 5:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $65.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the 6 train to 77th street and walk from there.
5. The Pierre
The Pierre is a 5-star, Taj Hotel that is known for serving the best New York afternoon tea of them all.
Therefore, if you’re looking to get extra fancy and refined while in the big apple, then The Pierre is THE place to be.
I mean, it’s straight-up historic since it was first opened in 1930 and overlooks none other than Central Park itself.
However, the real magic happens once you step inside their refined tea room and indulge in an experience that Town and Country fondly refers to as the “best afternoon tea in New York City.”
And, if it’s good enough for them then it’s good enough for me.
So, start by choosing from among several loose leaf teas from Palais des Thes. Although not gonna lie, the signature Pierre Blend (cardamom, orange, ginger, cinnamon, etc.) is my personal fave.
Then, swan dive into a selection of tea sandwiches that include mini lobster rolls, spiced chicken tartlets, and deviled eggs on brioche, among other things.
Finally, when you’re ready for the sweetness, indulge in some fresh cranberry scones (with Devonshire cream, lemon curd, and raspberry preserves), followed by an array of pastries like coffee opera cake, flavored macarons, and strawberry lemon pavlovas.
See, gastronomic dreams really do come true when you order the best afternoon tea in NYC.
Address: 2 East 61st Street (on Fifth Avenue), New York, NY 10065
Hours: Served from 2:00 pm to 6:00 pm daily.
Price: Starts at $74.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the N/R/W train to 5th Avenue and 59th Street station and walk from there.
Best Afternoon Tea in NYC – Midtown
6. The Palm Court at the Plaza Hotel
Possibly the most famous entry on this list of top picks for the best afternoon tea in NYC, the Palm Court has a reputation for excellence and can be conveniently found on Fifth Avenue, overlooking Central Park.
Now, is it my favorite New York afternoon tea on this list? No, probably not. I personally think it’s expensive and a bit overrated.
But, afternoon tea at the Plaza is an iconic New York experience that many people don’t want to miss out on since they’ve been serving tea here for well over 100 years.
So, channel your inner Eloise and make a reservation inside the Palm Court.
It basically feels like you’re dining inside the most ornate greenhouse that you ever did see since the large, open glass-ceilinged restaurant features ornate marble columns and is filled with tons of giant potted plants.
You’ll also love their wide selection of loose leaf teas, including my fave the Chai Imperial, which are perfectly complemented by savory items like pastrami cured salmon with horseradish on pumpernickel and a foie gras terrine on brioche toast.
Next, swan dive into homemade scones (served with Devonshire cream, yuzu/lemon curd, and fresh preserves) that are followed up with passion fruit macarons, lychee/rose coconut cake, and Bailey’s infused, dark chocolate Buche.
Yup, afternoon tea decadence to the extreme people.
Pro Tip: Make reservations WELL in advance and be aware of their smart casual dress code. Translation? Don’t show up in that ratty pair of sweatpants that you roam around the house in. They also serve a fun. Eloise-inspired afternoon tea for kids.
Address: 768 5th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Hours: Served daily from 10:30 am to 5:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $100 per person.
How to Get There: Take the N/R/W train to 59th street/Fifth Ave and walk from there.
7. The Russian Tea Room
After the Palm Court, this is probably the second most famous place to have the best afternoon tea in NYC.
And that’s probably because this upscale restaurant was initially founded in 1927 by the Russian Imperial Ballet.
Since then its become a veritable NYC institution where you can go for an enchanting afternoon tea that is served to you in vintage (but stylish) red booths that are perfectly complemented by dark green walls with gold-framed oil paintings and ornate gold light fixtures (designed to look like candles).
Yup, there’s definitely a fun, old-world vibe here that helps you feel like total royalty.
Add in a decadent menu of classic delights like Croque monsieur, curried chicken salad, Roquefort blue cheese blinis with pear and walnuts, scones, cupcakes, and assorted petit fours and you’ll love dining at the Russian Tea Room in NYC.
Pro Tip: Vegetarian, gluten-free, and children’s menus are also available.
Address: 150 West 57th Street, New York, NY, 10019
Hours: Served daily from 11:30 am to 4:30 pm.
Price: Starts at $80.00 per person
How to Get There: Take the N/R/W train to 57th Street and walk from there.
8. BG Restaurant
Bergdorf Goodman ain’t just a department store no more since they are routinely known for serving the best afternoon tea in NYC.
So, if you’re looking to live the luxe life in NYC for a hot minute, then consider stopping by for a New York afternoon tea experience to remember at this sleek, super upscale, wonderfully vibrant restaurant.
A magical place that was actually designed by the one and only, Kelly Wearstler.
Because if you want sweeping Central Park views – with pastel blue and yellow wrap-around chairs – to compliment your classic, three-tier tea service then that’s exactly what you’ll get at BG Restaurant.
Just do yourself a favor and make a reservation since, hi, this place is more than a little popular. You’ll also want to ask for a table by a window if you want to chillax in one of those super cool, aforementioned chairs.
FYI, you also won’t get much choice, besides the tea, since the menu is set and very traditional. Their signature Gotham Salad is really good though and what this place is known for.
Address: 754 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10019
Hours: Served daily from 3:00 pm to 5:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $45.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the N/R/W train to 59th street/Fifth Ave and walk from there.
9. The Whitby Hotel
I’m not gonna lie to you. If you’re looking for the best afternoon tea in NYC then most of the places you’ll find in midtown will be super swank (aka expensive) and offer a traditional, fancy AF tea experience (get those pinkies up people).
And the Whitby Hotel is no exception. But guess what? That’s not really a bad thing since they do classic, uber-chic dining really well.
So, once you take a seat in their vibrant, equal parts modern and trendy dining room, be prepared to sample a healthy afternoon tea that features all the classics (so you’ll still get your tea sandwiches, scones, and desserts) but with a series of simple changes that make the entire experience a wee bit lighter.
Therefore, think whipped cream instead of clotted cream. So, yeah, the changes are subtle.
As a result, you’ll still get to enjoy decadent delights like their red velvet macarons, carrot cake sticky buns (so damn good), and ginger layer cake – all of which are served atop Kit Kemp’s stunning Sailor’s Farewell Wedgwood china.
Pro Tip: Try to get a seat in their beautiful “Orangery”.
Address:18 West 56th Street, New York, NY 10019
Hours: Available on weekdays from 1:30 pm to 5:00 pm and on weekends from 12:00 pm to 5:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $50.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the F train to Rockefeller Center and walk from there.
10. The Blue Box Cafe
There’s almost nothing quite as “New York” as Tiffany’s and Co. on Fifth Avenue.
So, why not channel your inner Holly Golightly and enjoy the best afternoon tea in NYC at the Blue Box Cafe.
Because as the name suggests, this eatery is owned and operated by Tiffany and Co.
As such, it provides diners with a rich and extravagant afternoon tea amidst a sea of marble walls and turquoise dishes, chairs, and walls – a shade that is the same color as the company’s signature gift boxes.
And then there’s the tea service itself, which includes ultra snazzy things like almond cakes designed to look like Tiffany gift boxes, glitter-dusted clotted cream, and so-called “robin’s eggs” that are perfectly presented to you inside a nest made of phyllo dough.
Honestly, the food is just OKAY since you’re really just here for the experience.
Pro Tip: You MUST make reservations well in advance. Like, I’m talking months in advance.
Address: 727 5th Avenue, 4th Floor, New York, NY 10022
Hours: N/A. The store is currently closed for renovations but is set to reopen sometime this year.
Price: Starts at $52.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the N/R/W train to 59th/Fifth Ave station and walk from there.
11. Baccarat Hotel
If you’re looking for an incredibly whimsical yet super opulent experience then the Baccarat Hotel serves the best afternoon tea in NYC for you.
After all, this legendary brand is known for its extravagant crystal, which is used to adorn the lavish palaces of royal families all across the globe.
So, this New York afternoon tea has been designed to reflect the chic, upscale tea ceremonies that royalty itself routinely enjoys.
If you can, try their “Prince of Wales” menu which includes a premium selection of teas (the Red Moon and Cacao Chai are my faves) followed by an extravagant tower filled with savories (like lobster caviar medallions and foie gras macaroons), warm scones (with Devonshire clotted cream), and sweets (featuring chocolate pralines and tarte au citron).
Pro Tip: Come with your children so that they can enjoy the special “Petit Prince tea” offered here. You’ll also need to make a reservation at least 24 hours in advance.
Address: 28 W 53rd St, New York, NY 10019
Hours: Served daily from 12:00 pm to 4:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $110 per person.
How to Get There: Take the M train to 53rd street and walk from there.
12. High Teas at the Parisian Tea Room NYC
This is hands down my pick for the single BEST afternoon tea in NYC.
Not only is the food exceptional but the decor is next-level epic with crystal chandeliers, bright white walls, vintage oil paintings, and vibrant pink carpets that make you feel like you’re a high-roller in 1920s Paris.
So, have your camera at the ready and take lots of photos before swam diving into a very Parisian afternoon tea that features a green salad, a selection of tea sandwiches served on fresh brioche or flaky croissants (like Croque monsieur, chicken salad and watercress, and egg salad), and French macarons/pastries for dessert (apple tart, chocolate eclair, etc.).
Yeah, it’s not traditional but it’s awesome since the food is great and everything is served on an iconic, three-tier plate.
Pro Tip: You must make a reservation and try the “Du Hammam” tea.
Address: 347 W 36th St, New York, NY 10018
Hours: Open Tuesday through Sunday from 10:00 am to 4:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $55.00 per person but they also have a high tea for $75.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the A/C/E to Penn Station and walk from there.
13. Bluebird London
Looking out over Columbus Circle, Bluebird London serves the best afternoon tea in NYC if you’re looking for a high-end, contemporary, very British experience.
And that’s basically because this fine dining restaurant was started in London and then brought over to New York, where you can now enjoy an iconic British version of afternoon tea inside a chic, 1960s-era dining room.
Therefore, this classic tea service features an open-face trout sandwich, assorted pastries (with clotted cream and strawberry preserves/marmalade), quiche, cranberry scones, and classic cucumber finger sandwiches.
Pair it all with a pot of traditional English Breakfast tea and you have the perfect New York afternoon tea experience.
Address: 10 Columbus Cir, New York, NY 10019
Hours: Served on weekends from 12:00 pm to 3:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $55.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the 1 or A/C train to Columbus Circle and walk from there.
Best Afternoon Tea in NYC – Downtown
14. Cha-An Teahouse
Head to the trendy NOHO neighborhood and you’ll uncover this hidden gem of a restaurant tucked away at the top of a flight of stairs.
It’s a quiet place that offers diners a much-needed respite from the chaos of the city as they sit down inside a tranquil dining room designed to resemble a traditional Japanese tea house.
This theme then extends onto the menu, which is filled with Japanese-inspired delicacies like matcha tiramisu, homemade mochi, and black sesame Creme Brulee.
No, they don’t have an official afternoon tea menu or offer a classic afternoon tea service.
But, the desserts here are imaginative, whimsical, delicious, and super Instagrammable.
They also offer a premium selection of high-end Japanese teas that are perfect for anyone who wants real, authentic matcha.
Pro Tip: Get the peach white tea if you’re not into matcha.
Address: 230 East 9th St., 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10003
Hours: Open Thursday from 2:00 pm to 8:00 pm, Friday from 2:00 pm to 9:00 pm, Saturday from 1:00 pm to 9:00 pm, and Sunday from 1:00 pm to 7:00 pm.
Price: Dishes start at $11.00 each.
How to Get There: Take the R/W to 8th Street or the 4/5/6 train to Union Square and walk from there.
15. Tea & Sympathy
Looking for a low-key, totally British afternoon tea in NYC? If so then head over to Greenwich Village and give Tea & Sympathy a try.
It’s nothing fancy but is ideal if you’re looking for a low-key, very English tea experience that is well-priced and includes generous portions of British staples like Victoria Sponge (so dang good).
It’s also fairly popular, and small, so expect a crowd since they’ve been developing a following since 1991.
That’s why, make a reservation if you can and come extra hungry so that you can enjoy British classics like cheese and pickle/egg salad/cucumber and cream cheese sandwiches, fresh scones. and a giant strawberry cupcake (not too sweet).
Yup, they’re all delicious, come to you on a three-tiered plate, and are served inside this cozy restaurant. The staff is also super nice, making this another great pick for the best afternoon tea in NYC.
Address: 108 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10011
Hours: Served all day from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm, except on weekends when they open at 9:30 am.
Price: Starts at $40.00 per person for a single afternoon tea.
How to Get There: Take the 1/2/3/A/C/E train to 14th street and walk from there.
16. Lady Mendl’s Tea Salon
Consistently ranked as the best afternoon tea in NYC, Lady Mendl’s Tea Salon is known for offering a truly authentic Victorian-era experience.
After all, this posh AF eatery is tucked away inside a beautiful brownstone in Irving Place and offers an elegant, traditional English afternoon tea that includes no less than five different courses.
So, come hungry and start off with a seasonal soup that is closely followed by an assortment of finger sandwiches, fresh scones, a vanilla crepe cake (courtesy of Lady M), and a plate of fruit/macaron petit fours.
Therefore, be sure to reserve a seat (reservations are mandatory) on one of their cozy couches and relax by the fireplace as you dig into a New York afternoon tea to remember.
Address: 56 Irving Place, New York, NY 10003
Hours: Served Thursday and Friday from 1.00 pm to 4.00 pm and Saturday and Sunday from 12:00 pm to 5:00 pm.
Price: $65 per person
How to Get There: Take the N/R/W/4/5/6 to Union Square and walk from there.
17. Bosie Tea Parlor
First opened in 2011, Bosie Tea Parlor is a great place to go if you want an affordable afternoon tea in NYC that has a supremely chill vibe about it.
After all, this cool West Village eatery has a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes it an ideal place for a solo New York afternoon tea experience.
Plus, while you’re here, you get to enjoy all of the best afternoon tea in NYC classics like triangle tea sandwiches (including the very British chutney and cheddar variety), tea cakes, madeleines, fresh scones, and macarons.
The service is also top-notch making this a great place to go for the perfect New York afternoon tea experience.
Address: 10 Morton Street, New York, NY 10014
Hours: Served daily from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm.
Price: Starting at $39.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the 1 train to Christopher Street or the D/F/M train to Washington Square and walk from there.
18. Prince Tea House
Located in the East Village, the country-chic facade of this quaint French tea house ushers you into a bright and airy dining room where you can order premium teas that have been imported directly from France.
So, after admiring the patterned hardwood floors, modern domed light fixtures, and charming blue/green accents against the bright white walls, sample their delightful finger sandwiches (aka ham and cheese on croissants for the win), fresh scones (with clotted cream and preserves), and signature desserts (like fresh macarons and crepe cake).
Plus, everything will be presented to you in an antique floral teapot and on a three-tier plate that features a gold bow on top – perfect for all those must-have Instagram photos.
People love this place though so be sure to make a reservation if you want to stop by on the weekend.
Pro Tip: They have ten locations in NYC alone so it’s easy to find a tea house near you. The organza bleu hot chocolate is also really good, as is the “almost Croque monsieur” if you’re not ordering afternoon tea. And you can’t leave without having the French Onion soup.
Address: 204 East 10th Street, New York, NY 10003
Hours: Open daily from 10:00 am to 4:00 pm, except on Monday.
Price: $55 per person.
How to Get There: Take the A/C/E to Penn Station and walk from there.
Best Afternoon Tea in NYC – Brooklyn
19. The Wiiliamsburg Hotel
Want to get out of Manhattan? If so then step inside the Millenial chic, Williamsburg Hotel and indulge in the best NYC high tea of them all.
Trust me, once you sit down at your uber-hip table, you’ll be bedazzled by twinkle lights strung all across the ceiling and by the stylish, exposed brick walls that surround you.
Add in some tufted leather banquettes, plush velvet pillows, natural mosaic floors, and graffiti-inspired murals and you have the perfect place to hang out in one of Brooklyn’s liveliest neighborhoods.
Next, take a seat inside The Lobby at this 5-star hotel and listen to live jazz music while enjoying a classic selection of homemade sweet and savory delights.
Highlights include cucumber and cream cheese tea sandwiches, cranberry scones (with homemade preserves and Devonshire cream), and earl grey-infused truffles.
Then, indulge in an expertly-curated selection of single-origin teas from luxury tea house Bellocq Tea Atelier, all of which are served in bright hand-painted bone china teapots.
Yup, just an all-around great place to go to enjoy the ultimate New York afternoon tea experience.
Address: 96 Wythe Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249
Hours: Served on weekends from 12:00 pm to 5:00 pm.
Price: Starts at $65.00 per person.
How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.
20. Brooklyn High Low
And last, but certainly, not least is the best afternoon tea in NYC brought you by Brooklyn High Low.
This is basically a classic tea house that features a charming vintage dining room filled with low tables and cozy antique chairs that create a sense of peace as you choose from one of three pre-fixe menus: . The Classic, The Vanderbilt, and The Heights.
Just think of your options as small, medium, and large afternoon tea selections that all include at least 75-minutes of premium tea service.
If you can, grab a table outside on their garden patio so that you can drink bottomless House Black Tea while choosing among cucumber/dill, Branston Pickle/Cheddar, and cream brie/jam finger sandwiches as presented on a three-tier plate.
Afterward, enjoy homemade scones with strawberry jam and clotted cream before digging into a plate brimming over with decadent desserts.
Address: 611 Vanderbilt Avenue, Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Hours: Offered daily from 12:00 pm to 3:30 pm.
Price: Starts at $48 per person.
How to Get There: Take the Q or the B train to 7th Avenue and walk from there.