Alright all you cool cats and uber-rad kittens, are you ready to check out the very best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer?
Because if there’s one thing I know it’s that generally boutique hotels = better service. Plus, you can’t really more centrally located than midtown Manhattan.
So, booking a room at one of the best boutique hotels in Midtown NYC is really a win, win people.
Sadly though, not all top NYC boutique hotels are created equal.
Therefore, you need expert tips from a 30+ year local – who has stayed in more NYC hotels then she cares to mention (seriously, I could write a novel and maybe I should) – like me to help show you the proverbial light at the end of the tunnel.
This way, you can stop low-key freaking out about whether you’re gonna get shanked while walking home from the subway at night (or am I the only one who is terrified by this?) and start looking forward to your upcoming vacay.
So, stop what you’re doing, take a second to read this article, and find the best boutique hotel Midtown NYC has to offer you!
This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure for more information. As an Amazon Associate, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.
My pick for the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer is the citizenM New York Times Square. For their price point they offer the best quality/service all around. 😊
Best Boutique Hotels NYC Midtown – Luxury
1. The Whitby Hotel
⭐️ Rating: 9.3/10.0 (134 Reviews) Price: $695 per night 📍Location: 18 W 56th St, New York, NY 10019 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Easily one of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer, The Whitby is a snazzy AF, 5-star hotel that is overflowing with next-level opulence – and all within a short 3-minute walk from the subway.
Now, while this place oozes luxe life vibes, the space is still super welcoming. So, you could easily walk around in sweatpants without feeling mega uncomfortable.
This is a fact that I personally love and can attest to since I’ve had afternoon tea here a bunch.
In fact, one woman loved it here so much that she actually MOVED in. Seriously, who has the budget for that?
Anyway, let’s move on to things you actually care about, like chic, modern rooms that come with individualized English-country-style decor that was developed by the only and only, Kit Kemp.
“I love the decor and feel of this hotel. The rooms are beautifully equipped and spacious. It is now my go-to place to stay in NYC.”
Sam (read more reviews now)
Add in flat-screen TVs, sitting areas/terraces (with sweeping views of NYC that make this one of the best hotels with Central Park views), floor-to-ceiling windows, and free WiFi and you have one of the best boutique hotels in Midtown NYC.
However, if you’re feeling extra fancy at one of the best boutique hotels in midtown then you can always upgrade to a 1, 2, or 3-bedroom suite with an additional living area, kitchen, butler service, multiple bathrooms, and 24-hour room service.
But, if that’s still not enough to make you swoon then be sure to visit their sleek lounge, gorgeous terrace, gym, an ORANGERY, and on-site movie theater (yes, like a real movie theater).
Pro Tip: They have a really unique afternoon tea service that I absolutely loved and deffo consider one of the best afternoon teas in NYC. So, this would be awesome to do either before or after a trip to MOMA.
2. Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York
⭐️ Rating: 8.8/10.0 (198 Reviews) Price: $845 per night 📍Location: 28 W 53rd St, New York, NY 10019 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Have a bit of cash to burn? If so then this is easily one of the best boutique hotels in Midtown NYC for you.
And that’s mainly because the Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is a stunning, 5-star property with a reputation for excellence that is unlike any of the other luxury boutique hotels in Midtown NYC on this list.
Accordingly, enjoy modern, Parisian-style rooms with Baccarat crystals, flat-screen TVs, free WiFi, minibars, wireless sound systems, sofas, and more.
“My second time staying here and wouldn’t stay anywhere else in the city.“
Ninoska (read more reviews now)
And then there’s the bathroom, which comes well-outfitted with a hairdryer, complimentary toiletries, slippers, and a plush bathrobe.
But, you can always upgrade to a suite at the 24-hour front desk if you want a distinct living area. Then, upgrade again if you want complimentary drinks and breakfast too.
Additionally, you’ll adore the property’s central location – right across the street from MOMA – and can even make use of ultra-rad amenities like a full spa, fitness room, indoor pool, and chauffeured car service.
However, you are forbidden from leaving one of the best boutique hotels in Midtown New York City without digging into some modern French dishes at their palatial-style restaurant, where afternoon tea is on offer.
3. 1 Hotel Central Park
⭐️ Rating: 8.4/10.0 (515 Reviews) Price: $249 per night 📍Location: 1414 6th Ave, New York, NY 10019 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
This sleek, 5-star property sits just minutes away from Central Park and is one of the only hotels on this list of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer that focuses on sustainability.
In fact, this brand actually has an outpost in Canada that makes for one of the best boutique hotels in Toronto.
So, their reputation for excellence extends to New York as 1 Hotel works hard to minimize its environmental impact.
“Excellent location and buzz in the bar/dining area. Guzel was exceptional as was Evan behind the bar. So much better than a corporeate hotel.”
Gareth (read more reviews now)
Therefore, you’ll find large swaths of plants scattered throughout the property, while rooms are designed using recycled materials like reclaimed wood.
Rustic but stylish suites also feature tablets with personalized apps, free WiFi, flat-screen TVs, Nespresso machines, laptop-compatible safes, plush robes, slipper socks, and yoga mats.
Patrons can also book luxurious in-room spa treatments or 24/7 room service if your feel like you need to treat yo’self.
And if you’re looking for one of the most romantic things to do in NYC, grab a picnic basket to go from their farm-to-table restaurant and relax in Central Park with your boo.
Local Tip: They offer you a free bag of snacks upon check-in and have an actual farm stand in the lobby. Also, be sure to stop by Jams during the weekend for brunch in NYC.
4. Merrion Row Hotel and Public House
⭐️ Rating: 8.7/10.0 (392 Reviews) Price: $249 per night 📍Location: 119 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Well situated near some of the best hotels in Times Square, the Merrion Row Hotel and Public House is a top-quality, 4-star hotel that is known for its Irish hospitality, central location, and elegant rooms.
So, when you book a room here expect to find stylish furniture that is complimented by free WiFi, in-room safes, shower-only bathrooms, designer toiletries, and flat-screen TVs (with cable).
“The rooms are beautifully appointed with well thought out layouts and beautiful fixtures and art with windows that open to the outside to let air in, with modern amenities. The beds were supremely comfortable and the entire property was sparkling clean. When I put the Do not Disturb sign on, I came back in the evening to fresh towels hanging with a lovely note from the staff on my door. The hotel has an interior staircase (as well as an elevator) for the 6 floor property and the staircase makes it feel as if you are in a beautiful home. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful.”
Joy (read more reviews now)
However, this is one of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown offers that features a unique, personal touch since Irish style and culture are seamlessly interwoven into the design of this place.
Plus, guests can hit the on-site gym before booking an airport transfer (fees apply) at the 24-hour front desk.
Just don’t leave without having an American breakfast, or some traditional Irish pub grub, at the Public House.
Although, if you’re not super hungry then you can always just grab a coffee to go at the property’s gourmet coffee shop instead.
5. Renaissance New York Times Square Hotel
⭐️ Rating: 8.5/10.0 (1267 Reviews) Price: $210 per night 📍Location: Two Times Square 714 Seventh Avenue At, W 48th St, New York, NY 10036 Details: Read more on Booking.com now!
Highly rated as one of the best Manhattan hotels with balconies, The Renaissance New York Times Square Hotel is perfect if you want to be in the heart of the city.
After all, this amazing, 4-star property offers guests fantastic service that is only outdone by the site’s stunning views of Times Square.
So, pick from among one of 312 soundproof rooms that include coffeemakers, flat-screen TVs, gold/blue accents, floor-to-ceiling windows, and wooden furniture.
And while WiFi is available, there is an associated fee. And I for one think is kind of lame.
“I loved everything about this hotel ! The location , the staff the rooms and decor I wanted to thank all the staff for making my moms birthday perfect and setting up a nice little birthday gift and special thanks to Jennifer and Omar thanks to everything there will define stay here in the future and the free breakfast was amazing as well!”
Tiffany (read more reviews now)
On the plus side, accommodations are relatively spacious and span an impressive 26 floors.
If you want, you also have the option of going full VIP and upgrading to the Club Room since it will give you premium access to a private lounge with snacks and a complimentary breakfast.
Because really, who doesn’t love food? #getinmybelly
6. Sonder The William
⭐️ Rating: 8.0/10.0 (433 Reviews) Price: $336 per night 📍Location: 24 E 39th St, New York, NY 10016 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Located in the awesome Murray Hill neighborhood, this plush, 4-star hotel sits a mere six minutes from Grand Central Terminal.
So, individually decorated, monochrome orange, yellow, blue, teal, or pink, green, orange, or green rooms are all well-located, with awesome premium rainfall showers.
The caliber of your stay is then further enhanced by kitchens, Nespresso machines, luxurious linens, flat-screen HDTVs, iPod sound systems, etc.
And if you can tear yourself away from your room inside one of the best boutique Hotels New York City Midtown has to offer, enjoy a meal at their cool, 19th-century-styled restaurant.
“Our room was so spacious for NYC and the amenities in-room were an added bonus. Within walking distance of Bryant Park, Rockefeller, Saks and many other Midtown locations! Will definitely stay again.”
Ellen (read more reviews now)
In fact, The Garden Room serves classic British fare and is super sleek, with rad design features like marble fireplaces and a terrace.
There’s also The Shakespeare Pub and The Raines Law Room speakeasy where you can sip on drinks in the evening before using your free guest pass at a local gym.
7. The Kimberly Hotel
⭐️ Rating: 9.0/10.0 (393 Reviews) Price: $478 per night 📍Location: 145 E 50th St, New York, NY 10022 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Tucked away in Midtown East, The Kimberly Hotel is a gorgeous little accomodation that is set within a high-rise edifice that features a super elaborate lobby.
Seriously, you should stop by JUST to see the lobby.
“Excellent! Returning guests and we will come back again for the 3rd time 🙂 From the moment you arrive you are greeted by a kind smiling gentleman at the door and the staff at the front desk go above and beyond for your requests.”
Jasmina (read more reviews now)
And then there are the rooms. They are traditional in style with WiFi (fee = lame), kitchenettes with microwaves, flat-screen TVs, free toiletries, and coffeemarkers.
Upgraded studios or 1/2 bedroom suites also offer liviing rooms, kitchens, and balconies, with in-room massages available for an additional fee.
Other on-site perks are 24/7 room service, a rooftop bar/lounge, an on-site steakhouse/Italian eatery, and free access to a gym with an indoor pool (for the WIN!).
Best Boutique Hotels NYC Midtown – Midrange
8. Archer Hotel New York
⭐️ Rating: 8.8/10.0 (738 Reviews) Price: $188 per night 📍Location: 45 W 38th St, New York, NY 10018 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Well-located just two short blocks from Bryant Park, this awesome, 4-star hotel sits inside a 22-story tall building that offers sweeping panoramas of the Empire State Building.
So, if you’re looking for one of the best boutique hotels in NYC with a view, then consider staying at The Archer Hotel.
“The staff were amazing. Very welcoming, nothing was too much trouble. Exceptional. Lovely hotel with great views, superb location, just minutes from everything but nice and quiet. Can’t rate it highly enough. If we go back to New York we will definitely stay here again.”
Jackie (read more reviews now!)
And while, sure, the views are awesome, this hotel is way more since guests get to use complimentary passes to access an off-site sports club.
Plus, all uniquely decorated rooms here come with 42″ flat-screen TVs, floor-to-ceiling windows, luxurious toiletries, free Wi-Fi, minifridges, and coffeemakers.
And if you need that “meaty goodness” hit up their on-site steak joint, AVA Social, for some seasonal American cuisine, Then, try kickin’ it (old school) at their fun lobby (with a patio) or rooftop bar.
9. citizenM New York Times Square Hotel
⭐️ Rating: 8.7/10.0 (2943 Reviews) Price: $149 per night 📍Location: 218 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
The advantage of staying with an established brand like citizenM is that you know you’re gonna get sleek designs paired with amazing amenities and fantastic service – all of which are available at a super reasonable price (at least by NYC standards).
Plus, you know these guys run a solid hotel since the company currently has hundreds of locations scattered all across the world.
And while I haven’t stayed at their NYC outpost personally, I can vouch for their high-caliber accommodations since I ADORED my stay at their Amsterdam location.
However, if you’ve never been to a citizenM hotel before then you can expect cozy but comfortable, modern rooms with smart TVs (you can stream Netflix for free), Wifi (free), floor-to-ceiling windows, and Hansgrohe rain showerheads in the bathrooms.
“The staff, everyone of them, were exceptional. The place itself is super convenient, kitschy, and a great value. Everything is either brand new or super clean. we picked it for the value, but we will absolutely go back for the experience.”
Davie (read more reviews now)
Plus, this is one of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer that is so tech-forward that there’s actually an in-room iPad (you can also use the app) that controls the blackout blinds, lighting, and thermostat.
In particular, though, this location boasts a 24-hour coffee shop (hell to the yeah), a rooftop bar (guests only), three terraces, and a state-of-the-art gym/yoga space with sweeping views on the 20th floor.
So, for my money, I would definitely consider a stay at one of the best boutique hotels in NYC.
Local Tip: Be forewarned that rooms are notoriously small at one of the cool boutique hotels in midtown NYC.
10. Iroquois New York Times Square
⭐️ Rating: 8.2/10.0 (1650 Reviews) Price: $183 per night 📍Location: 49 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Sitting just two blocks from Times Square, this well-located, high-end establishment is over two hundred years old.
As a result, it’s known for being one of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer that pays exquisite attention to detail, and service – something that is lacking in other nearby properties.
So, do expect a nightly turn-down service where Le Belge chocolates and a weather card are both left on your pillow (aww).
“The breakfast was delightful and then you could take it to go so you can get to your next Adventure. Everybody was so helpful and nice at this day all staff members.”
Vanesta (read more reviews now)
However, other on-site highlights include rooms with marble baths, soundproof windows, free WiFi, soft linens, 32″ flat-screen TVs, and D-E-L-I-S-H breakfast.
However, do upgrade to a suite to enjoy a private whirlpool tub in your room.
Then, order some fabulous French cuisine at their vibrant cocktail bar before getting an in-room massage, relaxing in the Finnish sauna, and doing some yoga at the 24-hour gym.
Local Tip: This is one of the few boutique hotels in Midtown Manhattan where you can get overnight shoeshine services, a copy of the New York Times, and complimentary drinks and coffee from the hotel lobby.
11. The Muse New York
⭐️ Rating: 8.1/10.0 (762 Reviews) Price: $187 per night 📍Location: 130 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036 Details: Read more on Booking.com Now!
Looking for one of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has that is just a hop, skip, and jump away from Broadway?
If so then meet your brand new bestie, The Muse New York. See, this super snazzy, 4-star property is brimming over with individually decorated rooms that feature intense colors, marble bathrooms, and cool geometric patterns.
“Front desk staff was friendly, lobby and common areas were clean. Morning coffee was good, as was happy hour wine. Beds and pillows were comfortable.”
Stephanie (read more reviews now)
And while rooms lack coffeemakers and the property offers no breakfast options, you can snag yourself a coveted private balcony by booking a suite with additional living space.
However, for an extra luxurious stay, hit up the concierge who will be happy to arrange some VIP in-room spa services for you.
Additionally, four-legged friends are welcome to stay here and you can leave them in your room while you use the free rental bikes provided!
Local Tip: This place is noisy on weekends especially so bring earplugs. They also have a great wine happy hour you should take advantage of.
12. The Pearl Hotel
⭐️ Rating: 8.6/10.0 (918 Reviews) Price: $149 per night 📍Location: 233 W 49th St, New York, NY 10019 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
The Pearl Hotel had me at FREE breakfast and FREE snacks. After all, you know how ya’ girl feels about free food.
In all seriousness though, this is one of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has that is well-priced but that still has a solid 4-stars.
Therefore, this is one of the best budget boutique hotels in NYC that is just three streets away from Times Square and a mere 800 feet from the subway.
“A friend and I stayed for a week at the Pearl. We loved it! They are already serving breakfast in the hotel (I read that previously they weren’t), they cleaned our room every day, and the staff is amazing and super nice. There’s even this room were they leave free snacks which is so useful for when you come back after a long day of walking and just feel like having something sweet. Location is excellent too.”
Sasha (read more reviews now)
It also offers understated rooms with warm decor, microwaves, small fridges, flat-screen TVs, complimentary WiFi, coffeemakers, and suites with soaking tubs/sitting rooms/private balconies.
And if you want to kick your NYC date night up a notch, stop by their evening wine reception. Then, order some room service (available 24 hours) before hitting up the gym or grabbing a seat at this chill international restaurant.
13. Park South Hotel (part of JdV by Hyatt)
⭐️ Rating: 8.5/10.0 (186 Reviews) Price: $162 per night 📍Location: 124 E 28th St, New York, NY 10016 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
As a contender for one of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer, The Park South Hotel (part of JdV by Hyatt) is a super affordable, ultra-sleek accommodation in NoMad that sits inside a historic building from 1906.
“The hotel was amazing. The staff were very nice. The rooftop patio was very quaint with a nice view. The location was fabulous – close to everything. The hotel was extremely clean and the staff was very welcoming and attentive.”
Lee (read more reviews now)
It’s also a quick minute’s walk from the 28th Streat subway station and is well-outfitted with art-deco-inspired rooms that feature rainfall showers, bathrobes, luxurious toiletries, chandeliers, desks, Samsung smart TVs, black-and-white photos of NYC, and free WiFi.
Other on-site amenities include a poppin’ rooftop bar, a 24/7 gym, and a high-end restaurant.
Just as an FYI though, they can be a bit skimpy when it comes to toilet paper. And the breakfast is nothing special so deffo go elsewhere.
14. Executive Hotel Le Soleil New York
Rating: 8.2/10.0 (2396 Reviews) Price: $139 per night 📍Location: 38 W 36th St., New York, NY 10018 Details: Read More on Booking.com Now!
Well located near the Herald Square subway station on west 36th Street, Executive Hotel Le Soleil New York is a fantastic, 4-star hotel that is also super reasonably priced – like $139 per night well-priced.
And anyone who has searched for some of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown is known for knows that is a steal.
But, just because the rooms here are inexpensive doesn’t mean they skimp on service and quality.
After all, in-room highlights at one of the top boutique hotels in New York City include marble bathrooms, floor-to-ceiling windows, free Wi-Fi, 42″ flat-screen TVs, Keurig coffeemakers, complimentary Acca Kappa toiletries, and more.
“The hotel is located in a more than ideal location. The staff were more than helpful and always smiling. Anything I needed or requested, was available with no hesitation.”
Hutchinson (read more reviews now)
Although, if you really wanna get this PARTY started, upgrade to a deluxe suite with a separate bedroom, and a kitchen (PSST…request the one with a patio that has sweet views of the Empire State Building).
You can also enjoy an in-house breakfast and on-site parking (both for a fee) before hitting up their lobby cafe, cocktail bar, gym, and stylish urban restaurant.
15. Room Mate Grace Boutique Hotel
Rating: 8.4/10.0 (1000 Reviews) Price: $256 per night 📍Location: 125 W 45th St, New York, NY, 10036 Details: Read More Now!
If there’s one thing that Room Mate Grace Boutique Hotel is known for its next-level decor.
Because the rooms at one of the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer look like something out of Buckingham Palace. And no, this is NOT a drill.
So, expect mega-epic decor that is perfect for an impromptu Insta photo shoot…or twenty.
Aside from the decor though, this boutique hotel in New York City also offers guests flat-screen TVs, free WiFi, open-concept bathrooms, etc.
And if you get bored, just beeline it on over to the on-site gym, sauna, and indoor heated pool.
Just grab some breakfast from the daily buffet first before hanging out at the pool bar since this gastronomic delight is open until noon every day.
Best Boutique Hotels NYC Midtown FAQ
Which are the Best Boutique Hotels in Midtown?
The best boutique hotels in Midtown are:
- The Whitby (9.3/10.0 with 134 reviews)
- citizenM Times Square (8.7/10.0 with 2934 reviews)
- The Kimberly Hotel (9.0/10.0 with 391 reviews)
Which New York City Boutique Hotels have the Biggest Rooms?
The best boutique hotels in New York City with the BIGGEST rooms are:
- The Mercer in SoHo (8.3/10.0 with 112 reviews)
- The Bryant Park Hotel in Midtown (8.7/10.0 with 821 reviews)
- Sixty LES on the Lower East Side (7.2/10.0 with 1070 reviews)
Where do Celebrities Stay in NYC?
Celebrities in NYC are most likely to stay at:
- Gramercy Park Hotel
- The Bowery Hotel
- The SoHo Grand Hotel
- The Mercer Hotel
- The Hotel on Rivington
- The Carlyle: A Rosewood Hotel
- The Piere, A Taj Hotel
- Lotte New York Palace
- And more!
What are the Advantages of a Boutique Hotel?
Because boutiques hotels are smaller guests can enjoy more customized service.
Spaces also tend to be better designed, with more intimate touches, since owners are independent and have no brand guideines to adhere to.
Additionally, this means that owners have the freedom to offer a wider array of services that cater to the specifc needs of their customers.
Therefore, boutique hotels tend to offer greater value for your money when you book with an independently owned hotel as opposed to a chain.
Map of the Best Boutique Hotels Midtown NYC
My pick for the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer is the citizenM New York Times Square. For their price point they offer the best quality/service all around. 😊
Additional NYC Resources You’ll Love
There you have it! That pretty much concludes this ultra-rad post on the best boutique hotels NYC Midtown has to offer.
Tell me, did your picks for the best boutique hotels in Midtown NYC make the list? If not then let me know in the comments below.
